Members Mark Vs Kirkland Signature Golf Ball Review | The Battle of the Grocers
Transcript
What is up my fellow golf ball addicts? Today is the battle of the grocery stores, which is a really weird thing to say out loud when we're talking about golf balls. But that's where we're at. A lot of these club membership places, Costco, Sam's Club, Meijer, and that's just the beginning, have now released their own golf balls. And let's find out who exactly they're for and which one you should be buying. Let's dive right in. As always, if you like this content, please like, comment, subscribe. All the free stuff. I have a membership. It just starts at a dollar a month. I'm getting ready to get into the final season here. And so pretty soon we'll have the top 100 golf balls, which is what I do every single year, where we take the best 100 I tested from this year and rank them all just for fun, because ultimately it's just about fitting. But still, that award season is really, really fun. So I'd highly encourage you to stick around, subscribe if you're new here. We appreciate it. You know, the Kirkland ball is, I think it's safe to say it's probably the most common golf ball that isn't from the main four or five. Right. If it's not a Strixon, if it's not a, you know, Titleist, if it's not a Callaway, Kirkland's can be found all over. And let's be honest, the main draw to that is the fact that they are so cheap and you're getting a three piece or a thing that is supposed to imitate the Pro V1. So we're going to talk about that quite a bit. That's going to be kind of a central theme here. But we're also going to look at the Members Mark Sam's Club ball, as well as the Meijer golf ball, just when it comes to the numbers, because I already did a review of that earlier in the year. So without further ado, let's go ahead and dive into some. Compression testing. Let's start with the Members Mark. Now, the Members Mark is usually a lot softer, which, yes, I got eighty nine there. Let's turn it and do it from a different spot. Ninety. OK, so that's a little more than I initially had had it earlier in the year. Eighty nine again. I'm going to call it eighty nine. So that is kind of a mid firm ball, but it's more Pro V1 level than what the Kirkland usually is. Usually Kirkland is like really, really, really firm. Let's test that now. We got the Kirkland here hitting it. Yeah, well over one hundred, so I'll try it again about one hundred and ten, so one hundred nine, one hundred and ten, one hundred and ten again, actually very consistent. So I like the symmetry there, one ten for the Kirkland and basically about eighty nine for the Members Mark. So as you can see from the rip, there are two big main differences. And also, if you'll notice, let's go and pull up the pricing and design. I'll put the Meijer up here so you can see it to the Meijer kind of sits around that, like one hundred and five range. So it's also a firmer golf ball now, firmer golf balls. Traditionally. They actually are less forgiving. They are also more explosive off the tee usually, so it's kind of just a ball striking thing. But if you look here, you'll notice the main draw. Like I said, look at that pricing. I mean, you can get Members Mark for as low as fourteen dollars a dozen for a three piece urethane golf ball. And then it's no different when it comes to the Kirkland. The Kirkland is also that way. And what's really cool is you can also buy these golf balls if you're not a member of each. Now, you do have to pay a little bit more. I think I think you have to pay like a four or five dollar increase. But it's still. Regardless of that ends up being an amazing deal either way. So it's just it's kind of mind blowing how cheap the prices really are. It almost feels like there's got to be something missing, right? Because I mean, how can I pay fourteen dollars a dozen for a three piece urethane ball? Anyway, let's get into the actual designs of the golf ball. Now, if we take a look here, this is what the front of the members mark looks like. And yeah, you know, I mean, if you've ever been inside a Sam's Club, you recognize that logo. So it's pretty basic. I don't expect anything else. If we look at the Kirkland, you know, the Kirkland signature is always kind of bothered me because I don't like how long the words are. But I don't care when you're getting a golf ball this cheap, who gives a darn? You know what I mean? If we look on the side here, these are the alignment tools. I don't like either of these. You know, you guys know I like a nice thick black line, and I just don't think that these are even you got to use a Sharpie at this point. You can't really see either of them, and they're not good for lining up. So you're going to have to put a golf dot on there. You're going to have to do something. But yeah, I wish they would at least do it a little bit better. But again, with that price, you know, I can't be too picky on it because when it comes to something this cheap, as long as it gets by, it's usually pretty decent. So anyway, all right, now, without further ado, let's go out to the green side so we can see the chipping, we can see the putting, and we can see how these golf balls are green side. Well, that's definitely a tale of two different golf balls. So let's start with the Kirkland. You know, the Kirkland isn't the worst I've seen. I call it balanced. It's kind of in that middle to low. One thing I've discovered around the green this year is it's not the spin that's super important. It's that urethane coating. That coating, depending on how good of quality and how sticky it is, that's what's going to give you that tug, and you could see a clear difference there. The Kirkland, it was just okay, but boy, compared to the Sam's Club Member's Mark, you saw that Member's Mark going and stopping, and the Kirkland kind of acted like it wanted to, but it just, it isn't the same result. You know what I mean? It just wasn't there. I thought the checkup was a lot more consistent and better with Member's Mark. Kirkland, I thought, shot to the back every single time. The only thing I thought was that the Kirkland was a little bit better. The only way I could get the Kirkland to come near the hole was to play it like a bump and run kind of, you know, play it a lot more toward the front of the green and just let it roll, and for something that's three-piece urethane, again, it kind of goes to, I know that I'm getting a good deal, but the reason I want three-piece urethane is for that coating, so I have this, so it's a little disappointing, but let's get to the putting. All right, I've only got one of each of these golf balls, so I'm actually going to alternate them, so I don't usually do that. I usually do them in a row, but this is the Member's Mark. Very soft, rolls decent, it was kind of a little heavy, but it works, yeah, good distance control, I gave it a chance. Now we got the Kirkland. Oh, the same feel. I mean, they feel exactly the same. Oh, I needed that, y'all. I'd gone two tests without making one of those. I felt so bad. Every putt is $1 toward children's hospitals. Yeah, it's just, it's really dead in the hands. That one, I could tell I hit it way too far. It's soft. It's soft. It's soft. It's soft. And the roll's pretty good. Yeah, I mean, the roll's really good. That one actually did have a tiny bit of click, which I would expect. It's way firmer, right? But I gave him a chance. Let's try again. Third time's the charm here. Ah, a little bit of chug on that one, but I didn't hit it perfect. Boy, see, now I'm hitting it way too hard. Got to find that good in between. Come on. Ah, get there. I'm having trouble with that distance control. Yeah, I'm honestly surprised how close these two are when it comes to feel and sound off the putter. That Kirkland does have just a little more sound, but not much. Well, I finally got it to quit going past the hole, but at what cost? That's too hard. I just, guys, I've lost the putter. That's nice. Come on, be the one. It just slowed down too much. Had a great line on it. Hit it, hit it, hit it, hit it. Needed that. All right, starting with the member's mark here. Not a great swing. It's amazing how firm it feels. It was a slight mishit. I usually have it around the 85 to 90 compression range. It is really incredible how firm it feels. Like, they've made it to feel firmer than a 90, so that's kind of interesting. Now let's go to the Kirkland. Hmm. I thought that was a pretty good swing. For the most part, I'm not warm yet, but I mean, yeah, that's actually got a little bit of feedback in it. It is firm. That's why slower swingers I'm always not big on, but, like, it definitely does feel on the firmer side. Let's run it back. Member's mark again. Yeah, it's just, it does. The member's mark feels like 100 compression. It's not, but it just feels that way based on how they've designed it and they've done the layers. Yeah, these are, that's really, I like the explosiveness. The Kirkland, that was a really good strike. I felt the explosiveness. Sometimes the Kirkland's issue is that when you miss hit it, it really stings the hands, but when you hit it right, it feels really good. So I like the Kirkland because it's got some personality. Member's mark just kind of feels heavy and firm. It's never been a ball that I've been wowed by. I mean, I think it gets the job done, but if you're expecting a golf ball to make you feel something based on how it comes off the club, that's probably not your type of ball. All right, let's get into some, actually, no. We're going to mix it up a little bit. I'm throwing you a curve ball. Normally, this is where I would give you the performance data metrics and those are coming, but I'm actually going to swap the order. I'm going to go ahead and give you my conclusion now and I'm going to go ahead and give you my player profile now and then I'll get to the numbers and I'll tell you why and I'll be just completely transparent. The Kirkland numbers, this is my fourth test now in the last few years on a Kirkland ball and they always test the same. I test from the human element. Some people disagree with that. Some people like it. It is what it is, but one thing the human element, shows you that robotic testing doesn't, is it tells you how a golf ball sometimes will react when you aren't perfect, when you don't hit it in the center every single time. And average golfers need that. Whether you like it or not, they do because no human is out there with the same swing and the same perfect attack angle and everything. It just doesn't work, right? So, Kirkland, there is a legit argument based on the last four tests, including this one, that Kirkland is the most punishing golf ball on the market. When it comes to mishits, I have never seen a golf ball that just absolutely punishes you, whether it's in the hands for feel, whether it's off the tee, left and right, whether it's the spin, whether it's the distance loss. I think there's a legitimate argument that it is the worst. It's top five without question. There's not even a debate there, but there's a legit argument that it's the worst. This always negatively affects the numbers. Kirkland is a great Pro V1 imitator, for better or worse. If you're someone who plays a Pro V1, you're used to a Pro V1, you can still score really low with a Pro V1, you're a pretty good ball striker, you're going to be able to switch to the Kirkland model and have success. You will, you absolutely will. If you're used to playing a MaxFly Tour or TourX or whatever, you can probably make that switch and you'll be fine. But where I see people getting in trouble, and when I do fittings for people online, I always run into this. They're like, yeah, I tried the Kirkland for a while and I like it a lot, but, and I'm like, but let me guess, you're a 20 handicap. And they're like, well, yeah. And I'm like, it's not for you, bud. Like, I know it's cheap. I know it's a great value, but that's always the issue with the Kirkland. The members mark is going to be for someone who wants a lot of spin. Distance is not king here. You're not going to see explosiveness off the tee. You're not going to see explosiveness, you know, anywhere. But if you're a really slow swinger, you might be able to see a little bit, but honestly, that's not what this ball's for. It's about spin. It's about greenside checkup. It's a little bit more about control. And it is a little more forgiving just because it's an 89 compression. It's a lot softer. The Kirkland, like I said, it is a great pro V1 imitator for better or worse. If you're used to the pro V1, it's awesome. But if you're still learning this game and you're still shooting the high eighties, low nineties, low one hundreds, it is one of the most punishing, arguably punishing golf balls I've ever tested. Please play something else. And that's just my opinion. You can take the review hat off and put the opinion hat on for a second. I highly recommend that if you're still not a great ball striker, stay away from the Kirkland. It's ultra, you know, unforgiving. Now that we have that out of the way, sorry for the rant in the middle, but I wanted to get that out of the way because a lot of the times during these reviews, people see the numbers and they just start the hate comments. And I don't want that to be the case. I want you to understand the context of these numbers aren't gonna be great. Not that they're terrible, but they're just, they're not gonna be as great as you think they are. And it's because that's why I test from a human because if we did a robotic test, the Kirkland would do awesome because in the same place, every single time it's getting hit. We don't do that. An average golfer is going to pure a ball one to two out of 10 times. Just the truth of it, you know? All right, let's get to some numbers. Without further ado, this is the best part. Okay, now let's get into the numbers here. And this is my favorite part of the review here. There's actually some good stuff in here, despite what I said. 25 yard chip, if we look, 5,412, that's not bad. 5,472, yeah, that's pretty darn good actually, especially with that coating, I like it. The value there is insane on both golf balls. Now I will admit the hybrid performance from Meyer, I did get a little bit less with. I'm going to give it a little bit of grace. It is a low spin ball. I don't know if it's 71st out of 80. This was back when I was first starting the testing for this year and I was still kind of playing around with the chipping and I've done some retesting since then. I'd say it's a mid spin ball, but the truth is it's not as spinny as the other two. Meyer, the main issue I found is that it does not spin as much. And you'll see that throughout this review multiple times. So 60 yard pitch now, going into that, getting a little further. As you can see, the members mark did awesome at 17th out of 80, 8,239, that's enough to get it in the green. A low penetrating launch, but look at the Kirkland. A super low penetrating launch and 8,436, that's sixth out of 80. And then again, the Meyer kind of fell flat here, one of the lowest, one of the lowest. It just isn't as spinny as the other two, which is a shame because it costs the most. And you know what's funny about the Kirkland? I legit think that if I could get that launch angle up a little bit, so I use a 56 degree, I think if I had used a 58 or a 60, I think I could have got more spin out of it. So the Kirkland, I can see why a lot of you fall in love with it initially, because it spins like a maniac. Like when you pick up a golf ball for $14 a dozen, and that's the first thing you see on a wedge shot, like you see your ball rip back to you, you're gonna get excited. I get it, trust me, I completely get it. There was a couple of times in that testing where I was like, I hit a really solid one and I got like 10K. And I was like, that's cool. I don't see that very often. So I can understand why a lot of you like it on that spin alone. It spins, it really does. Nine iron full shots. Looking now, as you can see, not much for ball speed. Now this is where the hybrid performance comes in from Meyer. It is a rocket off the club. And you'll see that a couple of times as well, but low spin, right? Kind of a mid spin from the Meyer, a low spin from the Kirkland, a very, very, very low spin. Which is kind of Pro V1 like. Pro V1 has a very low launch. And a lot of the time it's a lower spin ball, but you can see the Kirkland actually had really good spin. 6,239. 6,033, 18.2, 102.3. So I mean, not great ball speed, but decent spin numbers. The members mark launches high. The Kirkland launches low. And then the Meyer is kind of in the middle there. So if you need distance, the Meyer's your king. What I like about the Kirkland though, is that it actually is one of the few golf balls I've seen this year that launches super low like this, right? And then the backspin is so high, it causes it to kind of do this and just fall down. And that's a really cool thing to see in person. I was talking to someone in a fitting about this the other day, and we were like geeking out about it. But it was like, you can, it's very few golf balls that you can just see do that and just fall down. It's a great descent angle. So much control there. That's definitely not my beef with the Kirkland. That's excellent. Again, I think the Kirkland would have had better ball speed and distance, if not, for the first time. Forgiveness. That was the main issue, right? Okay, going into 7-iron now. Now, I'm gonna show you the 7-iron, and then I'm gonna give you another disclaimer because there's been some confusion in the comments. So let's get to that. But first, let's look at the numbers. 117.2 on the members mark. That's not bad. That's kind of right in the middle there, average. Again, the Kirkland is super, super, super low. Again, it's a forgiveness thing. It's just, there are some times I would get 118, 119 out of it, but a slight miss hits, and it just punished me so bad. The Meyer, again, just explodes off the face. It's one of the best I've tested this year. Spin-wise, all three of these are low. The Meyer is the lowest I've seen this year. The Kirkland is one of the lowest by far. And then the members mark actually ends up as a low, but it actually looks high compared to the other two. Launch angles, we have mid, mid-high, and then we have a very, very low from the Kirkland again. And then we have a, yeah, okay, so a little bit better there. Boy, not much. Again, a really low from the hybrid. I don't know why all these grocery balls think that, well, yeah, I do, because they're trying to imitate the Pro-V, that's what everybody's trying to do. So they create these really low launching balls. It's not what most average golfers need. That's what bothers me. And a lot of you right now, this is a disclaimer. I know there's been confusion. A lot of you will look at that spin number and say, Nick, something's wrong. Why on earth are your spin numbers 3,000 with a seven iron? Well, I'll tell you why. One, I'm a natural low ball flight hitter. Two, I'm also a natural low spin hitter because I hit a draw and I already hit them low. That's a double whammy, okay? I'm using players distance irons to test this year. In hindsight, I probably should have thought about that a little bit more or changed my club selection up or got the lofts adjusted, but it's a 31 degree seven iron. And my dynamic loft, I checked the other day because I'm a natural low ball hitter. My dynamic loft is like 17 to 18 on average with a seven iron. That's why you're seeing that number. That's just the way I swing. The clubs aren't fitted to me. I apologize, that's on me. But the numbers are still relevant. They still show you what spins high and what spins low. I just know you're gonna see those numbers and go, whoa, 3,000, that's not right. My seven iron is like your five or four iron because that's what…
